•  
  •  
 

Abstract

Background: The scoping review of published studies aims to explore what practices and processes can improve equity (horizontal and vertical) in countries that adopted Area Health Management (AHM) utilizing the “Six Building Blocks Plus” (SBBP) concept.

Method: An electronic search was conducted from the inception to January 27, 2021, from 6 databases (Embase, Social Sciences, Web of Science, PubMed, CINAHL, and WHO) and the gray literature. The inclusion criteria were AH, SBBP, and equity. Data extraction was using a standardized data collection form.

Results: This scoping review includes 63 full-text studies. SBBP are identical in the horizontal and vertical equity. However, the majority of SBBP were health service delivery, leadership & governance, and health workforce. The result showed the practice and process to improve health equity were related to a health service delivery (HSD).

Conclusion: The included study showed horizontal and vertical equity. The equity measurement focused on utilization. AHM utilizing SBBP was mostly showed in HSD, HWF, leadership & governance. This review indicates that HSD could improve equity or cooperate with other SBBP by increasing healthcare accessibility and utilization. The demographic factor that affected equity is ethnicity. Therefore, HSD in area health was crucial in enhancing health promotion equity in different areas, specific diseases, and target patients.

Keywords: Equity, Area health, Six building blocks, Health service delivery, People participation

References

[1] World Health Organization [WHO]. Health systems equity 2016 [updated 2020 June 22; cited 2020 May 4]. Available from: http://www.who.int/healthsystems/topics/equity/en/.

[2] Saavedra PA. A study of the impact of decentralization on access to service delivery. cited 2020 December 15]. Available from: https://scholarworks.gsu.edu/pmap_diss/40/.

[3] World Health Organization [WHO]. Effective management of decentralized health systems. 2012 November. cited 2020 December 15]. Available from: http://www.who.int/pmnch/media/news/2012/implementation_decentralisation_04112012.pdf.

[4] Smith BC. Decentralisation: the territorial dimension of the state. London: Allen & Unwin; 1985. p. 194-6.

[5] Gilson L, Kilima P, Tanner M. Local government decentralisation and the health sector in Tanzania. PADUA 1994;14: 451-77.

[6] Institute of Medicine Committee on Quality of Health Care in A. Crossing the quality chasm: a new health system for the 21st century. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US) Copyright 2001 by the National Academy of Sciences; 2001.

[7] World Health Organization [WHO]. Human rights [2021 December 14]. Available from: https://www.who.int/healthtopics/human-rights#tab¼tab_1.

[8] Cookson R, Asaria M, Ali S, Shaw R, Doran T, Goldblatt P. Health equity monitoring for healthcare quality assurance. Soc Sci Med 2018;198:148-56.

[9] Wagstaff A, van Doorslaer E, Paci P. On the measurement of horizontal inequity in the delivery of health care. J Health Econ 1991;10(2):169-205.

[10] O'Donnell O vDE, Wagstaff A, Lindelow M. Measuring and explaining inequity in health service delivery. Chapter 15. In: Analysing health equity using household survey data e a guide to techniques and their implementation. Washington DC: The World Bank; 2008.

[11] World Health Organization [WHO]. Monitoring the building blocks of health systems: a handbook of indicators and their measurement strategies [2021 December 14]. Available from: https://www.who.int/healthinfo/systems/WHO_MBHSS_2010_full_web.pdf.

[12] Service plan by six building blocks plus [2021 December 14]. Available from: https://wwwnno.moph.go.th/NHDL/ServicePlan/2558-hr1-6BBplus-service-plan.pdf.

[13] World Health Organization [WHO]. Ottawa charter for health promotion [2021 December 15]. Available from: https://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/129532/Ottawa_Charter.pdf

[14] Liberati A, Altman D, Tetzlaff J. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. BMJ 2009;339.

[15] Booth A. Searching for qualitative research for inclusion in systematic reviews: a structured methodological review. Syst Rev 2016;5(1):74.

[16] Cochrane Organization. Cochrane methods equity [2021 December 15]. Available from: https://methods.cochrane.org/equity/projects/evidence-equity/progress-plus.

[17] Elo S, Kyngas H. The qualitative content analysis process. J Adv Nurs 2008;62 1:107-15.

[18] Bengtsson M. How to plan and perform a qualitative study using content analysis. NursingPlus Open 2016;2:8-14.

[19] Doorslaer E, Wagstaff A, Burg H, Christiansen T, De Graeve D, Duchesne I, et al. Equity in the delivery of health care in Europe and the US. J Health Econ 2000;19:553-83.

[20] Kutzin J. Health financing for universal coverage and health system performance: concepts and implications for policy. Bull World Health Organ 2013;91:602-11.

[21] Landis JR, Koch GG. The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 1977;33(1):159-74.

[22] Creswell JW, Creswell JD. Research design: qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. 5th ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications; 2018.

[23] Wells G, Shea B, O'Connell D, Peterson j, Welch V, Losos M, et al. The newcastleeottawa scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of non-randomized studies in meta-analysis. 2000 [Available from: [cited 2020 December 15]. Available from: http://www.ohri.ca/programs/clinical_epidemiology/oxford.asp.

[24] Cochrane Organization. Cochrane effective practice and organisation of care [2021 december 15]. Available from: https://epoc.cochrane.org/resources/epoc-resources-reviewauthors.

[25] Bartholomew K, Morton SM, Atatoa Carr PE, Bandara DK, Grant CC. Provider engagement and choice in the lead maternity carer system: evidence from growing up in New Zealand. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol 2015;55(4):323-30.

[26] Katz A, Enns JE, Chateau D, Lix L, Jutte D, Edwards J, et al. Does a pay-for-performance program for primary care physicians alleviate health inequity in childhood vaccination rates? Int J Equity Health 2015;14:114.

[27] Poole T, Goodyear-Smith F, Petousis-Harris H, Desmond N, Exeter D, Pointon L, et al. Human papillomavirus vaccination in Auckland: reducing ethnic and socioeconomic inequities. Vaccine 2012;31(1):84-8.

[28] Musto R, Siever JE, Johnston JC, Seidel J, Rose MS, McNeil DA. Social equity in Human Papillomavirus vaccination: a natural experiment in Calgary Canada. BMC Publ Health 2013;13:640.

[29] Sandiford P, Buckley A, Holdsworth D, Tozer G, Scott N. Reducing ethnic inequalities in bowel screening participation in New Zealand: a randomised controlled trial of telephone follow-up for non-respondents. J Med Screen 2018. 969141318815719.

[30] Hudon A, Laliberte M, Hunt M, Feldman DE. Quality of physiotherapy services for injured workers compensated by workers' compensation in Quebec: a focus group study of physiotherapy professionals. Healthc Policy 2015;10(3): 32-47.

[31] Nakaima A, Sridharan S, Gardner B. Towards a performance measurement system for health equity in a local health integration network. Eval Progr Plann 2013;36(1):204-12.

[32] Jackson G, Tobias M. Potentially avoidable hospitalisations in New Zealand, 1989-98. Aust N Z J Publ Health 2001;25(3): 212-21.

[33] Tin Tin S, Elwood JM, Brown C, Sarfati D, Campbell I, Scott N, et al. Ethnic disparities in breast cancer survival in New Zealand: which factors contribute? BMC Cancer 2018; 18(1).

[34] Manyazewal T. Using the World Health Organization health system building blocks through survey of healthcare professionals to determine the performance of public healthcare facilities. Arch Publ Health 2017;75:50.

[35] Leesmidt VLS, Bamrungkhet W, Chimnoi S. Research and development of locality health system management in the universal coverage system. Nonthaburi: Health Systems Research Institue; 2011.

[36] Javanparast S, Baum F, Freeman T, Ziersch A, Henderson J, Mackean T. Collaborative population health planning between Australian primary health care organisations and local government: lost opportunity. Aust N Z J Publ Health 2019; 43(1):68-74.

[37] Hjern A, Haglund B, Persson G, Rosen M. Is there equity in access to health services for ethnic minorities in Sweden? Eur J Publ Health 2001;11(2):147-52.

[38] Vallgarda S. Ethics, equality and evidence in health promotion Danish guidelines for municipalities. Scand J Publ Health2014;42(4):337-43.

[39] Christie S, Fone D. Equity of access to tertiary hospitals in Wales: a travel time analysis. J Publ Health Med 2003;25(4): 344-50.

[40] Abbott S, Meyer J, Copperman J, Bentley J, Lanceley A. Quality criteria for patient advice and liaison services: what do patients and the public want? Health Expect 2005;8(2): 126-37.

[41] Brown C, Lilford R. Cross sectional study of performance indicators for English Primary Care Trusts: testing construct validity and identifying explanatory variables. BMC Health Serv Res 2006;6.

[42] Dyas JV, Moody L, Siriwardena AN. Improving research quality and health care in rural areas: a case study of the contribution of a teaching primary care trust. Qual Prim Care 2005;13(4):183-90.

[43] McDonald R, Harrison S. Autonomy and modernisation: the management of change in an English primary care trust. Health Soc Care Community 2004;12(3):194-201.

[44] Salway S, Mir G, Turner D, Ellison GT, Carter L, Gerrish K. Obstacles to "race equality" in the English National Health Service: insights from the healthcare commissioning arena. Soc Sci Med 2016;152:102-10.

[45] Erasmus E, Gilson L, Govender V, Nkosi M. Organisational culture and trust as influences over the implementation of equity-oriented policy in two South African case study hospitals. Int J Equity Health 2017;16(1):164.

[46] Maluka SO. Why are pro-poor exemption policies in Tanzania better implemented in some districts than in others? Int J Equity Health 2013;12:80.

[47] Darby C, Valentine N, Jl C, de Silva A. World health organization (WHO): strategy on measuring responsiveness. GPE Discussion Paper series 2000;23.

[48] Woodgate RL, Busolo DS, Crockett M, Dean RA, Amaladas MR, Plourde PJ. A qualitative study on African immigrant and refugee families' experiences of accessing primary health care services in Manitoba, Canada: it's not easy. Int J Equity Health 2017;16(1):5.

[49] Rolfe MI, Donoghue DA, Longman JM, Pilcher J, Kildea S, Kruske S, et al. The distribution of maternity services across rural and remote Australia: does it reflect population need? BMC Health Serv Res 2017;17.

[50] Lao C, Obertova Z, Brown C, Scott N, Edlin R, Gilling P, et al. Differences in survival between Maori and New Zealand Europeans with prostate cancer. Eur J Cancer Care 2016; 25(2):262-8.

[51] Zidar MN, Larm P, Tillgren P, Akhavan S. Non-attendance of mammographic screening: the roles of age and municipality in a population-based Swedish sample. Int J Equity Health 2015;14:157.

[52] Shiikha Y, Kruger E, Tennant M. Rural and remote dental services shortages: filling the gaps through geo-spatial analysis evidence-based targeting. Health Information Management Journal 2015;44(3):39-44.

[53] Seneviratne S, Campbell I, Scott N, Shirley R, Peni T, Lawrenson R. Ethnic differences in breast cancer survival in New Zealand: contributions of differences in screening, treatment, tumor biology, demographics and comorbidities. Cancer Causes Control : CCC (Cancer Causes Control) 2015; 26(12):1813-24.

[54] Robertson H. Diffusion OF the primary health care strategy IN a small district health board IN New Zealand. Nurs Prax N Z 2015;31(3):17-26.

[55] McGrail MR, Humphreys JS. Spatial access disparities to primary health care in rural and remote Australia. Geospatial health 2015;10(2):358.

[56] Bergh AM, Allanson E, Pattinson RC. What is needed for taking emergency obstetric and neonatal programmes to scale? Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol 2015;29(8): 1017-27.

[57] Calder K, Bidwell S, Brunton C, Pink R. Evaluation of the Canterbury under-18 seasonal influenza vaccination programme. N Z Med J 2014;127(1398):19-27.

[58] Brownhill S, Chang E, Bidewell J, Johnson A. A decision model for community nurses providing bereavement care. Br J Community Nurs 2013;18(3):133-9.

[59] Boyd J, Mackinnon MW, Severn A, Traynor JP, Whitworth CE, Metcalfe W. The delivery of renal replacement therapy in Scotland–why the geographic variation? QJM 2013;106(12):1077-85.

[60] Wilson D, Harding SA, Melton I, Lever NA, Stiles MK, Boddington D, et al. Geographic, ethnic and socioeconomic factors influencing access to implantable cardioverter defibrillators (ICDs) in New Zealand. Heart Lung Circ 2012; 21(9):576-81.

[61] Sandiford P, Mosquera D, Bramley D. Ethnic inequalities in incidence, survival and mortality from abdominal aortic aneurysm in New Zealand. J Epidemiol Community Health 2012;66(12):1097-103.

[62] Holman PA, Ruud T, Grepperud S. Horizontal equity and mental health care: a study of priority ratings by clinicians and teams at outpatient clinics. BMC Health Serv Res 2012; 12:162.

[63] Putland C, Baum FE, Ziersch AM. From causes to solutions– insights from lay knowledge about health inequalities. BMC Publ Health 2011;11:67.

[64] Woodland L, Burgner D, Paxton G, Zwi K. Health service delivery for newly arrived refugee children: a framework for good practice. J Paediatr Child Health 2010; 46(10):560-7.

[65] Roeger LS, Reed RL, Smith BP. Equity of access in the spatial distribution of GPs within an Australian metropolitan city. Aust J Prim Health 2010;16(4):284-90.

[66] Gallego G, Taylor SJ, Brien JaE. Funding and access to high cost medicines in public hospitals in Australia: decisionmakers' perspectives. Health Pol 2009;92(1):27-34.

[67] Ringback Weitoft G, Ericsson O, Lofroth E, Rosen M. Equal access to treatment? Population-based follow-up of drugs dispensed to patients after acute myocardial infarction in Sweden. Eur J Clin Pharmacol 2008;64(4):417-24.

[68] Mindell J, Klodawski E, Fitzpatrick J, Malhotra N, McKee M, Sanderson C. The impact of private-sector provision on equitable utilisation of coronary revascularisation in London. Heart 2008;94(8):1008-11.

[69] Baeza JI, Fitzgerald L, McGivern G. Change capacity: the route to service improvement in primary care. Qual Prim Care 2008;16(6):401-7.

[70] West YR, Kendrick BJL, Williamson DM. Evaluation of the impact of orthopaedic guidelines on referrals from primary care to a specialist department. Qual Prim Care 2007;15(1): 27-31.

[71] Laporte A, Croxford R, Coyte PC. Can a publicly funded home care system successfully allocate service based on perceived need rather than socioeconomic status? A Canadian experience. Health Soc Care Community 2007;15(2): 108-19.

[72] Strong M, Maheswaran R, Radford J. Socioeconomic deprivation, coronary heart disease prevalence and quality of care: a practice-level analysis in Rotherham using data from the new UK general practitioner Quality and Outcomes Framework. J Publ Health 2006;28(1):39-42.

[73] Sigfrid LA, Turner C, Crook D, Ray S. Using the UK primary care Quality and Outcomes Framework to audit health care equity: preliminary data on diabetes management. J Public Health 2006;28(3):221-5.

[74] Morris E, Landes D. The equity of access to orthodontic dental care for children in the North East of England. Publ Health2006;120(4):359-63.

[75] Mansell JL, Beadle-Brown J, Skidmore C, Whelton B, Hutchinson A. People with learning disabilities in 'out-ofarea' residential placements: 1. Policy context. J Intellect Disabil Res 2006;50(11):837-44.

[76] Lyon AK, Bardhan M, Barker P, Wilson P. Computer technology and the childhood immunization programme: an investigation of low uptake rates in Coventry Primary Care Trust. J Publ Health 2006;28(4):351-4.

[77] Kildea S, Kruske S, Bowell L. Maternity emergency care: short course in maternity emergencies for remote area health staff with no midwifery qualifications. Aust J Rural Health 2006;14(3):111-5.

[78] Thalanay M, Derrough T. Pneumococcal vaccination: uptake and coverage in primary care. Qual Prim Care 2005;13(3): 131-7.

[79] Barriball L, While A, Münch L. An audit of clinical supervision in primary care. Br J Community Nurs 2004;9(9): 389-97.

[80] McCarthy A, Hegney D, Brown L, Gilbar P, Brodribb TR, Swales J. Characteristics of chemotherapy practice in rural and remote area health facilities in Queensland. Aust J Rural Health 2003;11(3):138-44.

[81] Low A, Ithindi T, Low A. A step too far? Making health equity interventions in Namibia more sufficient. Int J Equity Health2003;2(1):5.

[82] Lindstrom K, Engstrom S, Bengtsson C, Borgquist L. Determinants of hospitalisation rates: does primary health care play a role?Scand J Prim Health Care 2003;21(1):15.

[83] Denley J, Rao JN, Stewart A. How do patients rate the quality of consultations in primary care? A patient enablement survey from practices within a primary care trust in Sandwell. Qual Prim Care 2003;11(3):181-7.

[84] Tran M, Phung H, Young L, Hopper U, Hillman K. Patterns and characteristics of ethnic Australian women utilising ethno-specific maternal and child health services. Aust Health Rev 2002;25(4):107-18.

[85] Kemp L, Comino E, Harris E, Killian D. A decade of change in a community health service: a shift to acute and shortterm care. Aust Health Rev 2002;25(6):148-55.

[86] Johnston G, Wilkinson D. Increasingly inequitable distribution of general practitioners in Australia, 1986-96. Aust N Z J Publ Health 2001;25(1):66-70.

[87] Russell-Weisz D, Hindle D. High length-of-stay outliers under casemix funding of a remote rural community with a high proportion of aboriginal patients. Aust Health Rev 2000; 23(2):47-61.

[88] Metcalfe W, MacLeod AM, Bennett D, Simpson K, Khan IH. Equity of renal replacement therapy utilization: a prospective population-based study. QJM 1999;92(11):637-42.

[89] Manson-Siddle CJ, Robinson MB. Super Profile analysis of socioeconomic variations in coronary investigation and revascularisation rates. J Epidemiol Community Health 1998; 52(8):507-12.

[90] Stone DH. An approach to the analysis of health care needs and resources. J Epidemiol Community Health 1980;34(3): 208-11.

[91] The National Center for Biotechnology Information. Newcastle-ottawa quality assessment form for cohort studies [cited 2021 december 15]. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK115843/bin/appe-fm3.pdf.

Download

Share

COinS