•  
  •  
 

NAKHARA (Journal of Environmental Design and Planning)

Publication Date

2026

Abstract

This study investigates how Indonesian architects navigate between global green building rating tools (GBRTs) and context-specific design strategies across different project types and scales. Using a comparative analysis of sixteen award-winning projects by six Indonesian architects, the research combines semi-structured interviews with document review and inductive coding to map design logics against core GBRT categories. The analysis is around six themes used by GBRTs—energy efficiency, material resources and cycles, water conservation, sustainable site development, indoor health and comfort, and building resilience and adaptability—and identifies two additional themes central to Indonesian practice yet largely absent from GBRT assessment—social collaboration in the design process and cultural values. Findings reveal that in small- to medium-scale private and CSR projects, architects exercise greater autonomy to implement low-tech, community-based strategies, including passive cooling, proximate and recycled materials, hydrological restoration, and collaborative building processes. By contrast, large, regulation-led government projects tend to limit sustainability to compliance requirements, resource accounting, and site-level mitigation, often marginalizing socio-cultural dimensions and constraining contextual innovation. Across all design themes, recurring misalignments appear between GBRTs’ measurable proxies and architects’ context-driven values. These frictions show that what counts as sustainability in GBRTs—simulation outputs, certifications, and prescriptive thresholds—does not consistently capture what sustains practice on the ground:  community resilience, ecological balance, and cultural continuity. In Indonesia, a context-aligned recalibration that recognizes adaptive comfort, vernacular material cycles, and participatory processes can keep GBRTs rigorous while making them more responsive to climatic logics, cultural values, and long-term stewardship norms.

DOI

10.54028/NJ202625608

First Page

1

Last Page

32

Download

Share

COinS
 
 

To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.