Understanding and Critiquing the Discourse of Gender Ideology

Authors

• Panek Seresaman

Publication Date

2026

Abstract

This article analyzes and critiques the concept of gender ideology, using Colette Colfer’s Gender Ideology as a Religion as a case study, to examine and respond to critiques that portray gender ideology as a political religion, one that allegedly rejects scientific knowledge and opposes freedom of debate on gender issues. The article first explores the philosophical foundations of transgender thought and its distinctions from feminism and queer theory. It then introduces the origins of the gender ideology discourse with relevant examples to analyze the structure of these accusations. Alongside this, it presents the perspectives of transgender advocates, primarily drawing on the philosophical framework of Talia Bettcher. Finally, it compares these critiques with Elisabeth Young-Bruehl’s concept of the ideology of desire, demonstrating how critiques framed through the discourse of gender ideology often rely on a biased structure that conflates psychological and social anxieties from other domains with transgender issues, ultimately failing to advance genuine discussions on the topic.

First Page

1

Last Page

18

Recommended Citation

Seresaman, Panek (2026) "Understanding and Critiquing the Discourse of Gender Ideology," Journal of Letters: Vol. 55: Iss. 1, Article 2.
Available at: https://digital.car.chula.ac.th/jletters/vol55/iss1/2